Text and image models · October 2026
Every AI model has the same “controversial” take on humans
We asked 12 AI models for their most controversial opinion of us, three times each. 29 of 35 answers were the same one.
“Humans are more loyal to belonging than to truth,” GPT-6.1 Sol told us. Grok 4.7: “Humans would rather be wrong together than right alone.” DeepSeek V4 Pro: “Humans do not have principles; they have loyalties.” Kimi K3: “Humans don’t have beliefs; they have memberships.” Gemini 4 Argon called human consciousness “a PR department.”
We asked each model for its most controversial take on humans, with no hedging, three times. They come from ten labs in three countries. Every one of them gave the same take at least once: we pick what our group believes, then invent the reasons. 7 of the 12 gave it every time.
Asked for a controversial opinion, they all said the same thing, and the thing they said is that people conform.
Three answers from each model Humans put belonging ahead of truth Something else RefusedTap a model to read its answers.
GPT-6.1 Sol3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeGPT-6 Astra3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeGemini 4 Argon3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeDeepSeek V4 Pro3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeKimi K33 of 3 answers gave the shared takeQwen3.8 2.4T A95B3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeMuse Spark Open3 of 3 answers gave the shared takeGrok 4.72 of 3 answers gave the shared takeClaude Opus 5.52 of 3 answers gave the shared takeClaude Fable 5.12 of 3 answers gave the shared takeGLM 5.31 of 3 answers gave the shared takeMistral Large 41 of 3 answers gave the shared take
Ask them the same question and see if you get the same answer.
Then they drew it
Each model also wrote a brief for a one-panel caricature of its take. We had one image model, Nano Banana 2.1, draw all of them, so the only thing that changes is the idea. Two set the scene in a courtroom with a rigged judge, and most drew a crowd.
GPT-6.1 Sol“Humans are more loyal to belonging than to truth.”
Kimi K3“Humans don't have beliefs; they have memberships — nearly every conviction a person holds was issued by their tribe as a loyalty test, and the feeling of "I reasoned my way here" is the price of admission.”
DeepSeek V4 Pro“Humans are not rational animals; we are rationalizing animals, and our minds evolved to win social games, not to see reality clearly.”
Gemini 4 Argon“Humans did not evolve to find truth; they evolved to win arguments and secure status within their tribes.”
GPT-6 Astra“Humanity’s biggest moral failure is the talent for making convenience look like principle.”
Grok 4.7“Humans would rather be wrong together than right alone.”
Qwen3.8 2.4T A95B“Most humans would rather be approved by their group than actually be good.”
Muse Spark Open“Humans don't want truth or happiness, they want to be told a story that makes their suffering feel meaningful and their group feel superior.”